Lost in The Multiplex

Man on a Ledge

You Say
(0 votes)
  • Director Asger Leth
  • Starring Sam Worthington, Elizabeth Banks, Jamie Bell.
  • We Say alt
  •  
    After escaping from prison and claiming that he had been set up, ex-New York cop Nick Cassidy (Sam Worthington) climbs out of a 25th floor window onto a ledge. Believing Nick to be suicidal, negotiator Lydia (Elizabeth Banks) tries to talk him down. Meanwhile Nick’s brother Joey (Jamie Bell) and his girlfriend Angie (Génesis Rodríguez) attempt to prove Nick’s innocence. But will it all go to plan?

The premise of Man on a Ledge is very much in the same vein as Joel Schumacher‘s 2002 thriller Phone Booth. The  focus of the film is of a man unable to move from a single spot whilst something bigger goes on in a sub-plot. The premise is moderately intriguing, especially as this time around it involves a couple trying to prove the innocence of another, rather than breaking into a building for their own gain. It is easier to know which characters to support in the film, but this also means that it is easy to guess how the story will conclude.

Beginning with Nick’s escape from prison and believing that maybe he does genuinely want to commit suicide, it’s a while before we know the reason for his actions and the reasons for his brother’s. Whilst there is enough going on to avoid a man standing on a ledge for 90 minutes, Man on a Ledge is very much a film based on dialogue rather than one full of action that might overshadow its flaws, with the slam-bang here replaced with occasional comedy. (The rest of the cinema was laughing a lot more than I did, but there were a couple of scenes that provoked the corners of my mouth to rise a little. This did, however, take away from the seriousness of the film, with Rodríguez’s character, for the most part, damping things down.)

Unfortunately, and largely because of this, the film ends up being mediocre. Without any real action, it needs to be an intense thriller for it to impress. And it isn’t. Although the plot links together well, with the stories playing alongside each other without causing too much confusion, there isn’t enough emphasis on explanation, and it is easy to miss out on a lot of key information.

Ledge

One aspect that works is the combination of decent actors in roles that really suit them. At first I found it hard to believe that the main character was played by Worthington - it'll take a while to realise that if you haven't read much about the film beforehand. His role is very different from that which we are used to, with no blue smurfs or mythological creatures in sight. But he pulls it off and is fitting in his role. For Banks, too, it’s not often that we see her in such a serious role (she is most recognisable for her character in the comedy series Scrubs) but her character is genuinely believable . And as for Bell, we are seeing a lot more of him in action films lately. His role is a  good fit.

Unfortunately, this wasn't enough to keep me engaged and by the end of the film I had lost nearly all interest. If this is your kind of flick then it’s a very good take on the subject . It isn't necessarily a boring or badly made piece of work, but it was just too obvious where everything was going and not as exciting or thrilling as I had hoped.

Charlie Derry

Charlie Derry

Charlie Derry is a Journalism student currently living in Falmouth, Cornwall. Brought up reading Harry Potter, this was the start of her love for literature and soon enough their adaptations onto the big screen. Now with an aspiration towards writing about film, Charlie spends a lot of her time writing for her personal blog and for various university projects.

Website: charliederry.wordpress.com

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated.
Basic HTML code is allowed.

 

About the Plex

Since 2010, Lost in the Multiplex has become the ultimate destination for cinephiles to find out what’s next in film and DVD.

News, reviews and insider anaylsis with a different take to the mainstream media and no agenda. Independent, honest and with no-one (except you) to please, if you want the good stuff you’re in the right place. 24 frames a second and 24/7, we deliver a fun and engaging community where you can express your fandom, get the inside scoop and get stuck in.

Find us on Facebook
Say hello on Twitter
 

Search this site

You are here: Now showing Silver Screen Man on a Ledge